Today I’d like to talk about the absolutely lovely idea of breaking up. It’s not fun. Breaking up with a guy is perhaps the most painful thing that I do. Why? Well, I have this weird little phobia of wasting time, and I feel that every other guy on the planet has this phobia because–surprise!–I’m prone to mental distortions of the world around me. Hurray for high anxiety! In all seriousness, though, I always think that a guy I’ve broken up with will resent me because I’ve been wasting his time while we were dating. But I don’t want to be resented at all.
So the question is, how do you break up with a guy who’s perfectly…well…perfect in terms of what you need right now without hurting his feelings? Hell, how do you do it at all?
I have no problem breaking up with a guy I hate. I learned to do that with my first ex. Basically, you say, “I’m not very sorry for saying this, but I hate you. The end. There will be no ‘to be continued.’” And if you’re just not feeling a guy, you say, “I’m sorry, but I’m just not feeling it. We have major incompatibility issues.” But if the guy is nice, handsome, and oh-so-sweet, what the hell are you supposed to do about that? You can’t say, “Hey, you are everything Hugh Grant wishes he could be in his movies, but it’s just not working for me because I have a martyr complex.” Or can you?
Seriously, the only rational approach is to be honest in these sorts of situations, but what if the honest truth is that the only reason you need to break up is because…well, because you’re a neurotic with high anxiety who’s developed major trust issues due to all sorts of guys lying to you in your past? That seems like you’re throwing all your baggage at him right before you head out the door to catch your flight. And you know he’s only going to say, “It’s okay that you have trust issues. We’ll work them out together.”
No…no…no, it’s really not okay that I have trust issues. And unless you’re a trained therapist, I don’t think you can help me work them out.
In this case, the only thing to do is to lie by omission. I don’t condone lying in general, but if the only way to get out of a quickly developing relationship that you’re not ready for due to said neuroticism is to lie, then I suggest you go for it. For instance, I will provide a break-up conversation with translated notes to indicate the extent to which you’re omitting certain details:
Break-upper: I’d really like to talk about something. I’ve been thinking. (Translation – I’d really like to talk about something. I’ve been playing scenarios of what could happen between us over and over again for the past few weeks, but I’ve suppressed my agonizing over this by forcing myself to face a phobia of swimming every other morning.)
Break-uppee: What’s on your mind?
Break-upper: I don’t like the kind of relationship that this is turning out to be, and I think we should end it. (Translation – I’m a psychotic freak suffering from lapses of depression regarding how my first ex-boyfriend emotionally abused me. You’re fantastic and all, but, as emo as it sounds, scarring like this lasts a long time.)
Break-uppee: This seems rather sudden.
Break-upper: Well, I haven’t had time to think about it until recently. (I’ve been considering how damaged I am since we got together, and I feel extraordinarily guilty that I haven’t brought anything up until now because I was happy and all. But now I’m about to explode if I have to cause any friction between us at a later date when we’ve gotten closer.)
Break-uppee: It’s okay. Don’t worry about it.
Break-upper: I’m really sorry. (Translation – Wow, I’m such a fucked up idiot, and I want to shoot myself in the head for subjecting you to this drama. How can I be any more of a tool?)
Break-uppee: Like I said, it’s okay.
Break-upper: Umm…I have to go. (Translation – Oh, that’s how.)
So, in the event of a break-up that you really have no reason to undergo besides your own crazy anxiety, there’s your guide to how to put it. Good luck.















